When setting boundaries makes you feel like the villain

Reddit has become Confession Central for millions of online users. The anonymity allows them to vent their true feelings. For some, it’s cathartic. For others, it’s an outlet for validation.

One Redditor took to the platform, saying that they thought therapy would help them heal. It had the opposite effect. Once they set boundaries, those closest to them started turning on them.

It’s a common thread for many. Every one of them said that when they asked for space, they were called “selfish” or “dramatic”. If you’re reading this, you can probably relate.

Maybe you said one sentence. One calm, reasonable sentence. And somehow you’re the one who has to leave the group chat.

A clash of perspective

Boundaries are supposed to feel like relief. Instead, they can feel like you’ve been handed a villain origin story.

BuzzFeed’s roundup of women who were “cast as the villain” makes this painfully clear. Think the “cold” childfree aunt or the sister-in-law who wanted a phone call before people showed up. Almost every woman labelled difficult was a woman who said no.

Therapists have a name for the mechanism behind that flip: DARVO (Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender).

You raise a completely fair concern, and twenty minutes later you’re the one apologising. It’s not because your boundary was unreasonable. It’s because your empathy and sense of fairness got hijacked before your brain could catch up.

Comforting in a “so it’s not just me” kind of way. Annoying otherwise.

You’re not broken

Life coach Kamini Wood, who works with high achievers recovering from burnout and people-pleasing, frames this pattern as a survival response.

It’s something you learned to feel safe, not evidence that you’re secretly difficult. The goal, as the self-worth expert puts it, isn’t becoming a new person. It’s stopping the self-abandonment that made you so easy to lean on in the first place.

And maybe that’s the real lightbulb moment. You don’t have to be the main character of a cautionary tale. You get to be the main character of your own life, the one who sets the plot, not the one apologising for having one.

Grace and boundaries are not opposites

Somewhere along the way, “nice” got confused with “endlessly available,” and women inherited the bill.

The ‘No Fun’ tax

Working mums who stick to bedtime rules can attest to this.

You’ll hear a version of the same story. Relatives roll their eyes, mutter that “Mummy’s strict,” and a well-run household becomes a personality problem.

Scary Mommy covered exactly this. A mother enforcing bedtime and screen limits, branded “no fun” for having the audacity to parent while also, you know, existing.

The internet’s verdict was unanimous: structure isn’t cruelty. It’s love with a schedule.

The couch that started it all

Then there’s the university student who said no to housing a stranger indefinitely and became, in her words, the fifth person to be asked and the first to say enough.

One firm “no” and she’s the antagonist in someone else’s housing crisis.

How to hold the line

  • Say it plainly, once: “This doesn’t work for me” needs no legal brief attached.
  • Let the discomfort be theirs to sit with: Their disappointment is not your emergency.
  • Keep a receipt: Not for revenge; for reality, on the days you start to wonder if you imagined the whole thing.
  • Remember: Guilt is a feeling, not a verdict. You can feel guilty and still be right.

“Somewhere in your development, you learned that your main value rested in taking care of and fixing others. You’re okay if they’re okay. At some point, this has become a way to avoid sitting with yourself and asking deeper questions about what you actually want from your life.” – Author Shon Faye, via Vogue.

FAQs

Why do I feel guilty right after setting a totally reasonable boundary?

Guilt is a feeling, not a verdict. If you’ve spent years being the reliable, accommodating one, your nervous system reads any new “no” as risky, even when it’s completely fair.

Is it normal for people to get more upset than the boundary warrants?

Very. The people most unsettled by a new boundary are usually the ones who benefited most from you not having one. Their reaction is information about them, not a referendum on you.

How do I set a boundary without sounding harsh?

Keep it short, calm, and free of over-explaining. One clear sentence, said once, does more work than a five-paragraph justification.

What if my boundary gets me labelled “difficult” at work specifically?

Research on workplace assertiveness shows women face a real bias here, not a personality gap. Something like “I’ve thought this through, and here’s where I land” has been shown to soften the reaction without you having to shrink the boundary itself.

Boundaries by the numbers 

StatSource
Women’s perceived competence drops 35%
when they’re as assertive as male colleagues 
Organizational psychologist
Adam Grant
Women are asked to take on low-reward,
unpromotable tasks 44% more often than men
Raft Cares
72% of women report burnout, about
10 points higher than men 
eMonitor
Only 40% of women say they feel able to
fully switch off from work 
Deloitte Women @ Work 2025 

You’re not the problem. They are

Being called difficult for having limits isn’t a character flaw. It’s usually a sign the limit was working exactly as intended.

Kindness is how you deliver the boundary. Firmness is what you do when it’s tested. You can hold empathy for someone’s disappointment while not changing your answer.

And if you feel you’re not getting the balance right, chat with a personal empowerment or confidence coach. Villain era, cancelled. Grace-and-boundaries era, fully booked.

Gabrielle Collard
Verified Coach
Verified for professional standards and commitment to clients. Read more Close

I’m a business and marketing coach specialising in alternative life design – escaping the 9-to-5, designing life after full-time work, or building a business on your terms. Email me at gabrielle@thecoachspace.com

Add comment

Relationships

Community blog

Stay in touch with Gabrielle

For news and offers directly from Gabrielle Collard, simply sign up below.